WESTERN SENSE AND INDIAN SENSIBILITY
By Dr. Luis Dias
“Like his films, the music of Satyajit Ray is a unique multi-layered blending of Western sense and Indian sensibility”, says the narrator of a 1984 NFDC (National Film Development Corporation) documentary, Music of Satyajit Ray (1984).
This year, the 51st edition of IFFI commemorates his birth centenary by screening several of his classic works.
Satyajit Ray (1921-1992) is a towering figure not only in Bengali but also world cinema. What might not be as well-known is what a consummate film-maker he was, immersing himself in all aspects of the creation of his films, including costume design and even writing, directing and recording his own scores.
“I was born into a musical family”, he said in the documentary. His paternal grandfather Upendrakishore Ray Chowdhury, apart from being a writer, illustrator, philosopher, publisher and amateur astronomer, was also a violinist and composer, who played the Indian flute and drum too. His maternal grandfather Kali Narayan Gupta was also a composer, and as he put it, everyone was a ‘natural singer’ on his mother’s side of the family. He grew up in an atmosphere of Robindro and Brahmo Sangeet.
Significantly, Ray was also exposed to western classical music from a very early age. It developed into a more serious interest when a school-friend’s record collection widened his horizons. He read up on composers, their works and musical forms in libraries as he couldn’t afford to buy books.
In his 1955 classic Pather Panchali (Song of the Little Road), Ray made Indian film history not only by using a Hindustani classical musician of the stature of sitar maestro Ustad Ravi Shankar, but also for employing the genre cinematically. Such collaborations with other stalwarts such as Ustad Vilayat Khan (sitar) and Ali Akbar Khan (sarod) created a new idiom of film music in India.
As such maestros were ‘often busy internationally’, sometime in the 1960s, Ray decided to take up composition himself. He was too much of a gentleman to say that both Shankar and Khan had differences of opinion with Ray on fitting the music to the film, which gave him the impetus to compose his own music. In the documentary he acknowledged having initial difficulties, but “achieved some proficiency over time”, he added modestly.
Like many other film composers, Ray composed at the piano, using western notation. When he realized that his musicians weren’t familiar with western scores and used Indian, more specifically, ‘Bengali’ notation, he was unfazed. He learned to transcribe his music from one notation to the other; quite a feat.
Ray understood the power of silence and of natural sounds in augmenting the potency of a background score in his films. The musical accompaniment quite often can be very sparse, but this only serves to highlight it. Less is more. “I use music as discreetly as possible”, he stated.
He reiterated this point in his collection of essays titled Bishoy Chalachchitra (published in translation in 2006 as ‘Speaking of Films’), where he devoted a whole essay to ‘Background Music in Films’. “If background music is used without reason, it can only harm the film.”
“Ideally, the director should be aware where music would be needed in the film”, said Ray in the documentary, “assuming the director knows about music.”
His observations are often extraordinarily perceptive. In ‘Speaking of Films’, he writes, “It is risky to use the sarod as there is every chance that the twang of its strings will clash with the hard consonants used in the dialogue, thereby distorting the music.”
Charulata (1964) was Ray’s most satisfying experience as a music director, with musical links in its very structure. Ray believed that all film directors and composers should avoid hackneyed formulas, worn-out conventions of mindlessly using a certain kind of music to denote happiness, another for sadness or suspense, and so on.
Inevitable comparisons have been made with Rabindranath Tagore and Ravi Shankar in Ray’s ability to combine Western and Indian influences to create his own trademark form, a path-setter for others to follow in his footsteps. No other film director has quite matched the command of music and score-writing that Ray had.
Apart from a few films such as ‘Shakespeare Wallah’ a 1965 Merchant Ivory Production, he chose to write background scores for his own films, for his own “personal pleasure” as he described it.
The celebrated French film composer and conductor Maurice Jarre (1924-2009) spoke admiringly of Ray’s music, terming it “haunting and soul stirring at the same time”. I think the commentator Anita Mukherjee in the NFDC film sums up Ray’s music even more succinctly, “imaginative, not melodramatic; balanced, not exuberant; functional, not decorative.” The same adjectives would have fitted just as well to his cinematography, further demonstrating how intertwined the aural and visual world were in the brilliant mind of Satyajit Ray.